Should You Buy Circle's SPAC Stock?

Plus: Inside Circle's SPAC, Salvadorans BTC skeptical and more |

What you need to know today in crypto and beyond  July 9, 2021 Sponsored By:     Welcome to The Node.   If you were forwarded this newsletter and would like to receive it, sign up here.   Questions? Feedback? We'd love to hear from you! Simply reply to this email.   –Daniel Kuhn Today's must-reads Top Shelf 'WE'RE DOING IT': Square is building a bitcoin hardware wallet, CEO Jack Dorsey tweeted yesterday. The company announced it has started assembling a team to build a mobile-friendly, "assisted-self-custody" solution, emphasizing it's in the drawing-board stage.    CRYPTO  WARY: A recent survey suggests the majority of El Salvador citizens are wary of their president's push to implement the country's newly crafted and legislated Bitcoin Law. Around 54% of respondents viewed the law as "not at all correct" and 24% thought it was "only a little correct."  CIRCLING IN: Circle announced Thursday it is listing on the New York Stock Exchange via an acquisition by a SPAC, in a move that may add transparency to the stablecoin market. A peak at Circle's internals – i.e., its SEC regulatory report – reveals some curiosities. Circle lost over $156 million on its buyout and subsequent jettisoning of the crypto exchange Poloniex, disclosed a $2 million loss to email fraudsters and reportedly makes more from "transaction and treasury services," with clients including Dapper Labs, Compound Labs and FTX, than its main USDC business.    –Helene Braun  A message from Nexo Your digital assets deserve a savings account in their BEST INTEREST. Leading crypto lender Nexo treats you, your crypto and your fiat to industry-best Crypto & Fiat services, featuring:    * Up to 12% interest on digital assets, paid out daily! * Yields available on BTC, ETH, LTC, BCH, XRP, XLM, EOS, TRX, LINK, BNB, PAXG, USDT, USDC, TUSD, PAX, DAI, HUSD, GBP and EUR. * No minimum or maximum limits on funds deposited, offering infinite opportunities to earn. * #ZeroFees on all transactions. * Military-grade wallet security and top-tier insurance on all custodial assets with SOC 2 Type 2 certified crypto custodian BitGo.   Get started at nexo.io "[Stablecoins] do deserve a greater degree of transparency."   –Circle CEO Jeremy Allaire, on CoinDesk's "First Mover" A message from CoinDesk The Investor's Perspective on the Bitcoin Taproot Upgrade Taproot is a bundle of three upgrades to Bitcoin aimed at improving network security, privacy and scalability. At the same time, it poses some potential drawbacks to Bitcoin including risks of low adoption, unintended privacy shortcomings and Bitcoin community disappointment and fracturing.   CoinDesk Research's newest report dives into the economic impact and investment implications of the Taproot upgrade. Download the full report. What others are writing... Off-Chain Signals   Hong Kong-based software company Meitu is facing a $17 million impairment charge relating to its BTC holdings (Decrypt) Bloomberg editors pen a screed against crypto, calling "what used to be a sideshow" a "systemic risk" What People Don't Want in a NFT Collectible Drop (NFTs.WTF) A battle for power is being fought between different DeFi protocols in the "Curve Wars" (Rekt)   –D.K. A message from DeversiFi You've heard of DeFi, but have you heard of DeversiFi? DeversiFi is the easiest way to access DeFi opportunities on Ethereum: invest, trade and send tokens without paying gas fees. This summer we're launching our full suite of tools – from managing your portfolio, to providing liquidity through our AMMs and earning rewards.  DeversiFi is the place to be. So go on, what are you waiting for?    Click here to use DeversiFi today. Putting the news in perspective The Takeaway Should You Buy Circle Stock When It Goes Public? Circle, a longtime fixture of the cryptocurrency ecosystem, announced yesterday that it will go public via a SPAC, at a valuation of $4.5 billion. Though the big money will be going to insiders already in the SPAC, it still gives retail investors an opportunity to make a long-term bet on a company that has a real shot at becoming central to the crypto economy. If you're considering buying into the offering, read on for some key facts and factors. Circle was founded in 2013, making it truly venerable by crypto standards. But the company spent many years wandering the desert in search of a defining purpose: It has at various times dabbled with bitcoin, with non-crypto payments and with crypto exchanges. Starting in 2018, Circle seems to have truly found its calling with the USDC stablecoin. Stablecoins come in a few flavors, but USDC is of the fully backed variety: In exchange for deposits of low-tech dollars or equivalents, Circle prints dollar tokens to Ethereum and other blockchains.  Currently, stablecoins are mostly used by crypto traders looking for a way to safely park funds without making the expensive and slow swap to true fiat currency. But as crypto continues to grow as a sector, stablecoins are expected to have many more everyday financial applications, from payments to DeFi-based loans. (Disclosure: Circle has previously partnered with DCG, CoinDesk's parent company.) History and Character Circle was founded in 2013, a longevity that attests to solid management. From the start, Circle was very much on the corporate side of the cryptoverse, aiming at mainstream applications and big-name partnerships. If Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong is crypto's robotoid Mark Zuckerberg, Allaire is a crypto mini-Jamie Dimon, with the finance world's old-school sheen. That cultivation of respectability and trust has likely helped Circle establish its largest current revenue source, treasury and management services. But the real story for Circle is USDC. The stablecoin is a joint project between Circle and Coinbase, under an entity called Centre. USDC has been growing at a huge rate over the past year-plus, from $1 billion to $25 billion of USDC in circulation. That makes it a truly viable competitor to tether, currently the top stablecoin with about $63 billion in circulating supply. In a recent presentation Circle projected $83 billion in USDC issued by next year, and $200 billion by 2023. That would have a direct impact on Circle's bottom line through growing transaction fees and interest on reserves. Circle has been consolidating to focus on its success with USDC, primarily by unloading trading assets. In October 2019 it sold the Poloniex exchange, acquired just two years prior. In its SPAC filings Circle disclosed it lost $156 million on Poloniex. Circle also sold its OTC desk to Kraken in December 2019, and unloaded its retail trading app, Circle Invest, in February 2020.   USDC, Sector Risk and Regulation In a best-case scenario, the management of a USD stablecoin by a public, regulated U.S. entity could be a watershed, both practically and conceptually. It would be perhaps the most direct currency competition between a private company and the U.S. government since the post-Civil War crackdown on private bank currencies.  Within the cryptosphere, if USDC establishes trust it could continue to displace tether, which many critics see as a systemic risk because of its lack of reserve transparency. It could even be an alternative to a USD-backed stablecoin managed by the Federal Reserve, and some see the private route as preferable. However, there are doubts about whether that will happen. In recent conversations, Allaire has failed to answer questions about Circle's reserves to the satisfaction of onlookers, particularly regarding unknown "approved investments" backing USDC. Allaire has reaffirmed a commitment to transparency in a Twitter thread on June 8. Circle also faces obvious regulatory risk. Stablecoins are so novel that it's still unclear exactly what compliant management of one would mean. Many existing rules certainly apply in novel ways, and regulators may also want to create new rules over coming years. Those are both looming unknowns for would-be investors in Circle stock. Circle has a major potential advantage with regulators: Centre has ultimate control of USDC. In June, Centre froze $100,000 at the request of law enforcement. This level of control will, of course, be a barrier for the token's adoption by users who prioritize finality, or those who object on principle to a centralized token taking on a systemic role in crypto. But at least for now, stablecoins are primarily of interest to traders more focused on money than ideology, so the objections have been fairly muted. Either way, it's a bit of a devil's bargain – with truly decentralized stablecoins showing signs of long-term fragility, the main choice would seem to be between a centralized coin and one that appears quite risky. Though initially launched on Ethereum as an ERC-20 token, versions of USDC now run on a surprising number of blockchains, including Stellar and Solana. That diversity is important because, while there are methods to connect an ERC-20 to systems outside of Ethereum, native stablecoins are crucially faster for trades or operations on a given network. Tether, USDC's main competition, also runs on a number of networks, including EOS and Tron. SPACced Up If Circle has at points seemed like a company in search of a purpose, the timing of its public listing could also suggest a certain lack of ferocity. The listing will take place through a SPAC, essentially a reverse merger with an existing publicly listed entity.   These offerings have lower reporting and transparency requirements than a traditional IPO, and saw a huge surge during 2020 as the coronavirus pandemic somehow sent the NYSE into overdrive. Many of those SPACs have become disasters for retail investors, leaving serious egg on the face of promoters like Chamath Palihapatiya. With the bloom off the rose, the SPAC frenzy has fallen off dramatically. While Circle is late to the SPAC party, that may actually be in its favor. The wave of SPAC deflations has led the SEC to tighten some SPAC reporting standards in April, another cause of the SPAC slowdown. That suggests that many past or pending SPACs leaned on the reporting loophole while Circle is comfortable going to market under tighter standards and could improve on SPACs' spotty track record.   –David Z. Morris The cryptocurrency movement has never been so sprawling, reaching every corner of the planet.   Crypto State by CoinDesk aims to connect with local communities to explore this movement of financial disruption and how it trickles down to every corner of the globe, from DeFi investment opportunities to alternative ways to transact and store wealth.    We're making virtual stops with audiences in Nigeria, the Middle East and Southeast Asia this year. Register for the Crypto State virtual tour. The Chaser... ATTENTION: Scammers have been sending fraudulent emails with links to sites disguised to look like coindesk.com. If you are in doubt about a link, type https://www.coindesk.com directly into your browser; do not copy and paste. Remember, if something seems too good to be true, it probably is. The Node   A newsletter from CoinDesk   See Previous Editions Copyright © 2021 CoinDesk, All rights reserved.    250 Park Avenue South New York, NY 10003, USA You can manage your preferences here or unsubscribe from all CoinDesk email.